« Pipeline to Nowhere | Main | Russia's South Ravaged by Terrorist Attacks »


August 12, 2009
The Benefits of Bartering

This article was originally published in the National Review Online

night-moscow-may-09.jpg
Moscow River embankment on a summer night (Photo by Yuri Mamchur)

MOSCOW -- German Sterligov is well known here, but unlike Roman Abramovich, Oleg Deripaska, and other publicly flamboyant Russian billionaires, he is little known abroad. Sterligov neither sails the Caribbean nor drinks in London's Mayfair district; most of the time he lives a traditional peasant lifestyle deep in the Russian countryside with his wife and five children. In winter, their farm is accessible only by horse-drawn cart, and the nearest house is seven miles away. Sterligov's way of life makes a strong Russian Orthodox statement and amuses Moscow's public.

national-review-online-logo.jpgSterligov made his fortune in the 1990s running a large barter business. He founded a mercantile exchange where Russians traded products they were unable to buy or sell for cash. He lived the luxurious life of a billionaire and owned properties in Moscow, London, and Manhattan. In 2004, after an ill-fated bid for Russia's presidency, Sterligov sold everything and moved to the countryside.

However, the financial crisis forced him to put on a suit, get in a car, and find his way back to Moscow. Today, when not milling his own flour or hatching his turkeys and chickens, he occupies the Russian capital's newest skyscraper in the trendy Moscow City district. He rented "B" Tower's entire 26th floor and injected $50 million into the new business.

german-sterligov.jpgSterligov is an economic mastermind who's helping Russians overcome their country's lack of financial liquidity. His barter business model has been applied across Russia, particularly in Moscow. It may be the main reason why today, despite economic turmoil, Moscow's roads get paved and its skyscrapers continue to rise.

Sterligov's business model may appear confusing, but it's basically simple. If a provider of goods or services cannot find a client with money, they can offer their product in exchange for other goods or services. But since straight-up exchanges are the exception rather than the rule -- my company might need your goods, but your company might not accept my company's services as payment -- additional participants have to join the circle of exchanges in order to satisfy everyone's needs. Stergilov uses an advanced computer system to match product with consumer.

Often the series of exchanges begins with a debt. When Sterligov described the process to the Moscow Times, he used a steel company's debt of 1 billion rubles to a coal company as an example. The steel company might not have the money to pay its coal bill, but it will soon be able to put 1 billion rubles' worth of steel into the exchange. The coal company can provide a list of goods or services it will accept to fulfill the steel company's 1 billion ruble debt. Eventually, a company -- or a whole chain of companies -- will be able to bridge the gap, taking the steel and providing products or services either directly to the coal company, or that can be bartered or sold to its eventual benefit. When all is said and done, every player has made a fair exchange, and Sterligov's business has taken 1 percent of each transaction's value.

These proceeds are shared evenly between Sterligov's corporate center and the local outlets where participants sign up. Currently, there are 30 exchange offices in Russia. Sterligov's goal is to have 1,000 offices in Russia and then go international, so that Siberian condos could be paid for with the cash received for African bananas.

Russia's barter tradition comes not only from medieval history but also from the Soviet Union's latter days and the early 1990s, when workers wouldn't get salaries for months or years at a time and had to become creative to feed themselves and their loved ones. Factories paid workers with products, and babushkas from toy factories could be found at train stations exchanging stuffed animals for stuffed cabbage.

Modern Russians have witnessed several financial defaults and were naturally prepared for another crisis. Every Russian family lost its savings in 1991 during the Soviet Union's implosion. In 1998, the banking crisis swallowed the savings that Russians had accumulated after the painful rebound of the mid-1990s. Centuries of war and hardship seem to have prepared Russians for another economic "inconvenience."

Common people joke about the current economic conditions, saying that those who weren't wealthy didn't lose anything, those who accumulated billions during shady privatizations endured a fair adjustment of their fortunes, and no one became homeless or starved. Russians in general have not trusted banks since 1998, and very few families have kept their savings in financial institutions. When not spending money on travel, most Russians invest in condos, dachas, cars, jewelry, and clothing. While modern apartments and houses have safes, a common Russian household usually keeps its extra cash savings in even proportions of rubles, dollars, and euros under a mattress or in a closet.

moscow-night-traffic-jam.jpg
Despite tough economy Moscow's traffic is getting only tougher (Photo by Yuri Mamchur)

Russians were given private ownership of their properties after the Soviet Union fell, so only one in four Russians has a loan or a mortgage. However, mostly young citizens of major cities used loans to buy new vehicles and condos. Inspired by Russia's soaring economy, some young professionals got ahead of themselves and recently have had to sell or give up what they no longer can afford. Nevertheless, common Russian families buy everything with cash, and in case of an emergency, they often lean on extended family and friends rather than banks. A dacha or a car is something that has been earned over the years and cannot be affected by the crisis.

Russia's government spent nearly half a trillion U.S. dollars defending the ruble. However, a common Russian cannot appreciate the effort, as the ruble failed anyway -- yet another reason that peasants and businessmen alike have turned to the longstanding Russian tradition of barter.


-- Moscow native Yuri Mamchur founded and edits Russia Blog, directs the Discovery Institute's Real Russia Project, and serves as the executive director of the World Russia Forum. He is currently based in Nashville, Tenn., and is a member of Vanderbilt University's Owen Graduate School of Management MBA class of 2011.



TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.discovery.org/scripts/mt/mt-tb.cgi/22831

5 Comments

Computerized barter rings - excellent solution to economic apocalypse, the West will no doubt soon follow suit.

One caveat:

"Russia’s government spent nearly half a trillion U.S. dollars defending the ruble."

According to the CBR, Forex reserves fell from 600bn $ to 400bn $, and most of it wasn't for defending the ruble. And I don't think the ruble "failed" that badly when compared to the readjustments / devaluations of many other emerging market currencies.

As someone with graduate degrees in public finance and comparative economics, having spent my senior undergraduate year at Leningrad State University in the late 1980s as well as having worked in the Former Soviet Union for two years in the 1990s, I’m all too familiar with the “benefits” of bartering that Mr. Mamchur describes in his article. As described in the article, this type of system -- if one can call it that – is nothing new and while it has its roots in the pre soviet era, the limits and counterproductive results of this type of activity fully manifested itself in the socially corrosive and corrupting behaviors of na levo and blat, which are all too familiar to anyone who lived under an administrative command economy.

What’s more, barter is frighteningly inefficient, as more time is spent on arranging transactions as opposed to production, and the thought of basing an entire economic system on barter will do nothing but consign Russia to decades of anemic growth and further decline.

Sterligov, great Entrepreneur story! Bartering become fashionable these days. With economy stupid, I guess people become creative, including my self. I was always a favor of bartering. As you can imagine my contractor work is very slow to none some month. I have enough time to connect with other professionals and trade without cash. It 's win win situation.

If I may recommend, I use www.barterquest.com where I offer my service to barter items, other services and vacation rentals. Why pay when you can get it for free. This is my 2 cents!

While the merits of bartering may have wide applications internally; still, as an international medium of exchange it will undoubtedly prove too complex for sovereigns to abide it in the long term.
Better to organize city owned markets for some imports, and how about a new real value currency option for us peasants, folks? Like the Gold Ruble of Peter I, for example. We would like to be able to buy such currency here in the land of Pugachev, as a hedge. (Or perhaps a reissue of the gold beaver coin).
Lois & Cliff Clarke
Governors of Northwest Fur Company, Astoria OR

Here in America where cash is being used as a commodity to be overtaxed and assessed fees until there's nothing left, what has proven to be erosive is the current money exchange system. It appears to me that communities need to return to bartering in order to secure their needs and create better cohesion within each community. This way we can purchase for prices that are reasonable. The corruption one blogger wrote about here is attached to the dollar here in America not bartering. With bartering at least you know what you're getting in return. With the American Dollar being taxed every single time it exchanges hands there is no real value attached to it. How can one dollar be taxed thousands of times and still maintain value?

Leave a comment

Dotted Divider Line



Russia Blog presents up-to-date news, facts and commentary on the state of events in Russia and the former Soviet Union. The blog was created and is managed by Yuri Mamchur, Director of Discovery Institute's Real Russia Project, Executive Director of the World Russia Forum, and a Vanderbilt University MBA graduate.


 






Send an email to us at:
yuri@discovery.org
charles@discovery.org